top of page

Linking local business & community in Holmes Chapel, Goostrey, Brereton, Cranage & Allostock

More Than a Pint: The Hidden Cost of Hospitality

Apr 1
6 min read

By Rich, The Bottle Bank

Since I last took up the pen to create the finest piece of writing since Bill Shakespeare, quite a bit has happened. Firstly, I had a milestone birthday, so a huge and heartfelt thank you to everyone that sent me wishes, it meant a lot and was quite humbling. I’m not quite ready to admit what milestone it was, but it’s not hard to miss given the voracious appetite for mischief my team have!

We, along with many others in the hospitality and retail industry had to put prices up at the start of Feb because of the Government’s alcohol duty changes. Some may have old stock that is still filtering through, but for a lot of pubs, we buy weekly and so didn’t have an awful lot of wiggle room before we were making even less profit than before. We held off as long as we could, but prices had and have gone up. We’re also rapidly approaching April, and the time when the Chancellor’s revised minimum wage structure needs to be implemented, so if you see a second round of rises at some venues, then please be kind. The industry is being hit with rapid punches and we’re all trying our best to minimise the individual effects of them when they hit us, rather than implement the knockout blow of massive cumulative price hikes.

Hospitality was front and centre on a recent edition of BBC’s Question Time, with chef Tom Kerridge bringing a dose of reality to the panel. His key takeaway? Through multiple layers of taxation, hospitality is being squeezed to the point there is nothing left, with nothing around to replace it when it goes pop. His answer, a desperately needed VAT reduction to mirror that of the rest of Europe. Personally, I agree, that would solve a significant problem faced by the industry, particularly for food venues where they are being hit hugely from VAT charges on everything they sell, but cannot claim VAT on pretty much 95% of what they buy in to make the food we all eat.

I closed last month’s issue with the promise of going into a bit more detail around why you’re starting to see fewer places take cash these days. I did wonder if I was alone in making those decisions, because if I ever go out, I tend to just automatically pay by phone and not think about if cash is needed or not. Well I went into Manchester for a few birthday drinks, and thought I’d pay attention to what the policy was for the pubs I went in. The result, 3 out of the 4 pubs had little signs stating they were cashless. All were small, independent boozers focused on the small independent breweries I support – not one had Carling or Stella or John Smiths as an option so it may be different if that’s your usual tipple, but for me, it reinforced my view that it just isn’t practicable for small businesses to take cash these days.

So to that point, here’s a little breakdown to some of the costs involved in taking cash as an option in a small independent multi-site venue. Cash float for 2 venues took ~£1,000 of capital away from investment, just to be held in a safe in various denominations. To change that £1,000 into the denominations needed to give people the right change was £2.40 for every £100 changed. We changed around £1,000 a week at the bank costing on average around £1,200 a year. To bank the cash takings into my business account used to cost around £3,000 because the bank charged £1.20 per £100. To those who say I should have used it to pay my suppliers, we get a lot delivered by drivers or couriers, so handing them many hundreds of pounds just wasn’t feasible. Insurance premiums were an extra £1,000 for holding cash on the premises over a weekend. We’re now at £5,000 a year just to facilitate cash as a means of payment, and this is before any cost attributed to staff in handling cash. Every day cashing up at closing time was a 30 minute job. Making sure the till was right in the morning was a 15 minute job. That’s 45 minutes every day at each site. Taking the cash to the bank to change and pay in was originally a 20 minute task once or twice a week when the bank was in the village and Sandbach, but when they closed, it became a 1hr round trip and a 15 mile drive. Those tasks combined took roughly 650 hours a year to do, which at a loaded (includes PAYE, pension and NI contributions) £20 per hour is around £13,000. Added together, that was a total cost of £18,000 just to take cash across my bars, before adding in any losses from miscounting change or fake notes and the risk to my team of any burglary or mugging when going to the bank. I also had the cost of card payments to take into account, which were around £4,800 a year. The total annual cost to take payment for drinks across the bars was around £23,000 before any extra management time on accounts and VAT returns.

Compare this to how much it costs to only take card payments, and you’ll see why so many small businesses are moving to that. Let’s start off with the typical monthly charge from the card merchant. Several years ago, this was around £400 making it around £5,000 a year when you added on the machine rental charges. Perversely, by dropping cash as an option, when it came time to renew my card services, the increase in transaction volume and approximate doubling of revenue meant that my overall charges only went up by a quarter to £500 a month. The time to cash up was reduced to 5 minutes a day per site meaning a loaded cost of £1,250 a year. My insurance dropped by that thousand pounds at the time of renewal, the risk to my staff pretty much disappeared, and I had an extra £1,000 to reinvest in the business. Add them all together, and a total rough cost of £7,500 a year, plus an extra thousand pound saving and a drop more capital and it looks like that £12,000 a year is a conservative number.

One other thing that doesn’t get mentioned very often when talking about these things, is the cost of accounting. HMRC over the past few years have introduced something that is supposedly meant to ease the burden on businesses when it comes to capturing revenue and paying taxes. They called this Making Tax Digital, which you only have to ask any small business person and they would scoff, laugh and reply “Making Tax Harder you mean!” The reality is that HMRC now need detailed accounting of sales, something that when handling cash is just asking for trouble. Switching to card payments has meant I just print off a spreadsheet and my accountant can reconcile takings with transactions down to the individual sale if they so wish. My job is simpler, and I can throw as much data at HMRC as they need should they ever come knocking. All these things combine to me saving a whopping amount of time, money and stress by not taking cash, and you get a slightly cheaper drink as a result.

I began this mini-series at the start of the year because Katy asked me to write a little piece around hospitality and mental health. It’s resulted in a somewhat cathartic run of words, not just about how the difficulties felt internally by people in the industry and the hugely positive effect we have on our community are so very tightly entwined, but also by lifting the lid a little on the things we’re trying to contend with when opening our doors to our community. Pubs and bars and cafés and restaurants are not inherently expensive places to visit when you look at the value they give back, it’s just that the perception of their cost is being distorted by the lack of disposable income felt by everyone these days. We’re that space where you can come and spend as much or a little time as you want, come to socialise or to have a quiet few hours to yourself, come and feel welcomed, and to be a part of your community. Our doors are open, our heating is on, our toilets have loo roll. We bring your drinks to your table and take your empties away to do the washing up. You come to have your first date with us, arrange to celebrate your birthday, your marriage (or your break-up!), to toast your children before employing them years later. We gather to celebrate your life… and you come to us to not be alone. That in itself is worth it.

Love you all, Rich, Coral and the Bottle Bank team.

Recent Posts

See All
More Than a Pint: Life in the Bottle Bank Cellar

By Rich, The Bottle Bank October is here. The weather has a definite chill in the air and the nights are drawing in. After a cracking summer our autumnal decorations are up and the bar is set for Hall

 
 
 
More Than a Pint: Warming Up for Autumn

By Rich, The Bottle Bank It’s the middle of September; the weather has lost its summer warmth and the nights are drawing in a lot faster than I’d like them to! We’re all gearing up at the bar for what

 
 
 
The Village Kitchen... Soup for Your Soul

By Katy O’Regan Every winter, The Village Kitchen in Holmes Chapel brings a selection of soups to its seasonal specials menu and, for me, they have become part of my winter routine. There is something

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page